This is a very frequent assumption that I've heard on numerous occasions from teachers, students and recruiters: 'native speakers' are better at teaching pronunciation. Whenever you start discussing the 'native speaker' fallacy, this argument is bound to come up.
You know, 'native speakers' have the right, the natural accent.
They speak with the correct pronunciation.
And students can learn bad pronunciation from 'non-native speakers'.
As one of the students I interviewed for my PhD research project put it: "If a 'native speaker teaches me, I can hear the accent as it's supposed to be, and not as it was artificially learned".
And I imagine that the student believes that by listening to the accent, they'll be able to pick it up and improve their own pronunciation.
You might intuitively feel that there's something wrong with this assumption, but what arguments would you use to question it?
Or maybe you feel that there's a (substantial) grain of truth behind it, and that indeed 'native speakers' are better suited to teach pronunciation.
So let's look at this assumption in a bit more detail, OK?
Before we go any further, I'd like you to reflect on a few things yourself. Take a piece of paper and a pen (or a screen and keyboard for the techies reading this) and make some notes on the questions below:
- Is there something such as right or correct English pronunciation? If so, what is it?
- Are all 'native speakers' better models of pronunciation? Why(not)?
- Are students going to improve their pronunciation more with a 'native speaker' teacher? Why(not)?
- Is having a foreign accent a bad thing? Why(not)?
Ready with your notes?
Below is a short extract from a talk I gave at BBELT conference in Mexico where I addressed the assumption that 'native speakers' are better pronunciation teachers. Watch the video and compare with what you've noted down.
Over to you
When you're finished watching the video, think about the 4 questions above and the notes you made. Are 'native speaker' teachers better at teaching pronunciation?
Share your thoughts with us in the comments section below.
In order to be able to comment, you'll have to hit the 'Sign up' button in the top right hand corner. It'll only take 2 seconds to create the account, so don't let this stop you from leaving a comment below this post :)
Bonus content :)
Do you ever feel like...
...you're a bit stuck in a rut when it comes to teaching pronunciation?
...you need a fresh perspective?
...you want to know how to REALLY help your students improve their pronunciation?
...you'd like to know more about what research says about teaching pronunciation, but don't have time to read academic papers?
Then you're in the right place :)
I've put together for you a FREE 20-page pdf guide: 6 things every English teacher should know about teaching pronunciation.
AND, if the pdf guide wasn't enough, you're also getting a completely free 5-day email course about teaching pronunciation and English as a Lingua Franca.
Just click 'Send to Messenger' below and the guide will land in your FB Messenger inbox faster then you can say 'Send to Messenger' ;)
If you want to read more about the guide and the free email course before you decide, just click here.